Skip to content

Commit b5c597f

Browse files
ToolboxAidToolboxAid
committed
Drive MIDI Studio V2 to production-ready status by closing remaining UAT findings, enforcing SSoT ownership, and completing final audits - PR_26146_221-240-midi-studio-v2-production-ready-lane
1 parent 96040bb commit b5c597f

9 files changed

Lines changed: 284 additions & 0 deletions

‎docs/dev/reports/PR_26146_221_240_bundle_validation.md‎

Lines changed: 35 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
1+
# PR_26146_221_240 Bundle Validation
2+
3+
Status: PASS for MIDI Studio V2 production-ready lane with workspace-v2 WARN
4+
5+
Scope:
6+
- Baseline: PR_26146_201-220 final stabilization reports.
7+
- Purpose: production-ready closure for MIDI Studio V2 without new tabs, new architecture, or new systems.
8+
- Runtime changes: none required because PR201 reported no in-scope MIDI Studio FAIL items or normal-user blocker WARN items, and this lane revalidated the production workflow.
9+
- Artifact changes: PR221-240 reports plus required Codex review, command, coverage, and changed-file artifacts.
10+
11+
Validation Commands:
12+
- PASS `node --check tests/playwright/tools/MidiStudioV2.spec.mjs`
13+
- PASS `npx playwright test tests/playwright/tools/MidiStudioV2.spec.mjs --grep "PR161-200 release candidate" --reporter=line`
14+
- WARN `npm run test:workspace-v2`
15+
- PASS `git diff --check`
16+
17+
Targeted MIDI Studio Result:
18+
- PASS 2 tests, 56.1s on final run.
19+
- Verified complete user workflow, no duplicate editable ownership, Song Setup and Song Sheet, sequence generation, timeline editing, instrument editing, playback completion, import/export JSON, launch modes, export readiness, manifest readiness, red/unwired correctness, and Play/Stop correctness.
20+
21+
Workspace V2 Result:
22+
- WARN 49 passed, 23 failed.
23+
- Failures are Workspace Manager V2 tests outside MIDI Studio V2 scope.
24+
- Repeated failure: `#workspaceToolTiles [data-workspace-tool-id]` expected 11 tiles and received 12.
25+
- One Asset Manager V2 workspace session-context test timed out after 120000ms.
26+
- No failing workspace-v2 assertion was in MIDI Studio V2 or in PR221-240 changed files.
27+
28+
Production-Ready Gate:
29+
- PASS no remaining MIDI Studio FAIL item was found.
30+
- PASS no normal-user MIDI Studio workflow WARN item was found.
31+
- PASS incomplete future controls are red/unwired.
32+
- PASS duplicate editable ownership audit passed.
33+
- PASS import/export JSON roundtrip remained covered by targeted UAT.
34+
- PASS Play, Play Section, Play Sequence, Loop, Stop, completion state, playhead, and Bar/Beat synchronization remained covered by targeted UAT.
35+

‎docs/dev/reports/PR_26146_221_240_duplicate_usage_review.md‎

Lines changed: 35 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
1+
# PR_26146_221_240 Duplicate Usage Review
2+
3+
Status: PASS
4+
5+
Review Inputs:
6+
- PR201-220 SSoT ownership matrix.
7+
- PR201-220 UAT ready report.
8+
- PR201-220 remaining WARN/FAIL report.
9+
- Targeted MIDI Studio visible-control audit in Playwright.
10+
11+
Duplicate Edit Controls:
12+
- PASS no duplicate editable owner remains for single-value canonical fields.
13+
- PASS Song Details owns Name, Classification, generated ID display, and Notes.
14+
- PASS Song Sheet owns tempo, key, style, sections, sequence, generation targets, Parse Guided Song Sheet, and Regenerate Arrangement.
15+
- PASS Instruments tab owns editable instrument settings.
16+
- PASS Export tab owns rendered export controls and export readiness.
17+
- PASS Diagnostics remains read-only except explicit diagnostic actions.
18+
19+
Duplicate Dropdowns:
20+
- PASS no duplicate dropdown/edit surface was found for the same single-value canonical value.
21+
- PASS Octave Timeline instrument controls are quick select/mute/solo/hide, not duplicate instrument settings editors.
22+
23+
Duplicate State Models:
24+
- PASS selected song state derives from the canonical payload.
25+
- PASS selectedInstrumentId remains synchronized through the canonical tool state.
26+
- PASS timeline sections, labels, colors, diagnostics, and JSON Details derive from canonical song data after parse/regenerate.
27+
28+
Alias/Pass-through Variables:
29+
- PASS no PR221 runtime alias/pass-through change was required.
30+
- PASS PR201 targeted audit already confirmed visible controls are classified as working, read-only derived, or red/unwired future.
31+
32+
Hidden Fallback Behavior:
33+
- PASS MIDI Studio JSON import/export validation does not require hidden localStorage/sessionStorage data.
34+
- PASS incomplete future behavior remains red/unwired rather than silently falling back.
35+

‎docs/dev/reports/PR_26146_221_240_import_export_report.md‎

Lines changed: 27 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
1+
# PR_26146_221_240 Import and Export Report
2+
3+
Status: PASS with rendered audio future controls red/unwired
4+
5+
Import JSON:
6+
- PASS tool-only Import JSON loads canonical MIDI Studio toolState.
7+
- PASS JSON manifest import is separate from local MIDI file inspection/import.
8+
- PASS MIDI source inspection reports PASS/WARN/FAIL visibly.
9+
- PASS incomplete MIDI-to-canonical conversion remains red/unwired.
10+
11+
Export JSON:
12+
- PASS Export JSON produces canonical toolState JSON.
13+
- PASS exported JSON can be reimported and restores song metadata, sections, sequence, lanes, instruments, usage, and settings.
14+
- PASS JSON Details matches the canonical model after parse/regenerate and reimport.
15+
16+
Rendered Audio Export:
17+
- PASS Save WAV wording remains visible in Export.
18+
- PASS Save MP3 wording remains visible in Export.
19+
- PASS Save OGG wording remains visible in Export.
20+
- PASS rendered audio Save controls remain red/unwired because the renderer is not complete.
21+
- PASS rendered audio Save actions do not falsely claim file creation.
22+
- PASS SoundFont/render controls remain red/unwired.
23+
24+
Readiness:
25+
- PASS Export readiness summarizes selected song, classification, generated ID, sequence, sections, instruments, notes, and output status.
26+
- PASS Manifest readiness summarizes songs, classifications, game usage assignments, sections, sequence, instruments, notes, and export readiness.
27+

‎docs/dev/reports/PR_26146_221_240_instrument_report.md‎

Lines changed: 23 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,23 @@
1+
# PR_26146_221_240 Instrument Report
2+
3+
Status: PASS
4+
5+
Verified:
6+
- PASS selectedInstrumentId synchronization across Octave Timeline, Instruments tab, and audition keyboard.
7+
- PASS Duplicate instrument workflow.
8+
- PASS Move Up workflow.
9+
- PASS Move Down workflow.
10+
- PASS Delete safety workflow.
11+
- PASS Volume editing from Instruments tab.
12+
- PASS Pan/Balance editing from Instruments tab.
13+
- PASS Transpose editing from Instruments tab.
14+
- PASS Octave Range editing from Instruments tab.
15+
- PASS Audition keyboard uses selected instrument context.
16+
17+
Duplicate Edit Surfaces:
18+
- PASS Octave Timeline provides quick instrument selection and visibility/mute/solo controls only.
19+
- PASS Instruments tab owns GM Type/Patch and editable instrument configuration.
20+
21+
Remaining Future:
22+
- FUTURE advanced effects and incomplete advanced instrument controls remain red/unwired.
23+

‎docs/dev/reports/PR_26146_221_240_playback_report.md‎

Lines changed: 21 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,21 @@
1+
# PR_26146_221_240 Playback Report
2+
3+
Status: PASS
4+
5+
Verified:
6+
- PASS Play starts audible preview.
7+
- PASS Play Section targets the selected section path where wired.
8+
- PASS Play Sequence starts sequence timing preview.
9+
- PASS Loop reports looping and keeps playhead/Bar/Beat advancing.
10+
- PASS Stop exits playback and re-enables Play.
11+
- PASS natural completion reports completed state and re-enables Play.
12+
- PASS no stuck controls.
13+
- PASS no stuck playback state.
14+
15+
Playback Status:
16+
- PASS targeted UAT covered playing, looping, stopped, and completed status messages.
17+
- PASS loop cannot freeze playhead in the verified path.
18+
19+
Remaining Future:
20+
- No normal-user workflow blocker remains in this area.
21+

‎docs/dev/reports/PR_26146_221_240_production_ready_audit.md‎

Lines changed: 57 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,57 @@
1+
# PR_26146_221_240 Production Ready Audit
2+
3+
Overall Status: PASS for MIDI Studio V2 production-ready UAT, with workspace-v2 WARN outside MIDI Studio scope
4+
5+
PASS:
6+
- Song Setup metadata editing and generated ID behavior.
7+
- Song Sheet sections, custom sections, Available Sections, sequence builder, Parse Guided Song Sheet, and Regenerate Arrangement.
8+
- Octave Timeline canvas note editing, section colors/labels, frozen Bar/Beat, scrolling, and playback synchronization.
9+
- Instruments tab lifecycle, settings ownership, selectedInstrumentId sync, and audition keyboard.
10+
- Play, Play Section, Play Sequence, Loop, Stop, and natural completion behavior in targeted UAT.
11+
- Import JSON, Export JSON, JSON roundtrip persistence, workspace/tool launch split.
12+
- Export readiness and Manifest readiness honesty.
13+
- Diagnostics read-only ownership.
14+
- Red/unwired incomplete future controls.
15+
- No duplicate editable ownership by targeted visible-control audit.
16+
17+
WARN:
18+
- `npm run test:workspace-v2` still fails unrelated Workspace Manager V2 tests:
19+
- Workspace tool tile count expects 11 but UI renders 12.
20+
- One Asset Manager V2 workspace session-context test timed out.
21+
- These WARN items are not in MIDI Studio V2 scope and do not block MIDI Studio production-ready status.
22+
23+
FAIL:
24+
- None known in MIDI Studio V2 after this lane's targeted validation.
25+
26+
FUTURE:
27+
- Rendered audio export pipeline, including actual Save WAV/MP3/OGG file creation.
28+
- SoundFont/render configuration.
29+
- MIDI device input, recording, and advanced MIDI-to-canonical conversion.
30+
- Sequence drag/drop.
31+
- History, snapshots, revision history, autosave, and revert workflow.
32+
- Runtime Game Usage sync.
33+
- Workspace manifest proxy actions.
34+
35+
Final UAT Checklist:
36+
- Import JSON.
37+
- Select or create a song.
38+
- Edit Name, Classification, Tempo, Key, Style, and Notes.
39+
- Confirm generated ID updates.
40+
- Populate sections and custom sections.
41+
- Build Song Sequence.
42+
- Parse and regenerate arrangement.
43+
- Confirm Octave Timeline updates.
44+
- Edit notes on canvas.
45+
- Select and edit instruments.
46+
- Audition notes/instruments.
47+
- Play, loop, stop, and let playback complete naturally.
48+
- Export JSON.
49+
- Reimport JSON and verify persistence.
50+
- Review Export readiness and Manifest readiness.
51+
- Confirm future-only controls are red/unwired.
52+
53+
Recommended Next Phase After MIDI Studio:
54+
- Resolve the Workspace Manager V2 tool tile contract mismatch in a Workspace Manager lane.
55+
- Investigate the unrelated Asset Manager V2 workspace session timeout.
56+
- Implement a real rendered audio export renderer before unmarking Save WAV/MP3/OGG and SoundFont controls.
57+

‎docs/dev/reports/PR_26146_221_240_song_sheet_report.md‎

Lines changed: 29 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
1+
# PR_26146_221_240 Song Setup and Song Sheet Report
2+
3+
Status: PASS
4+
5+
Verified:
6+
- PASS Classification remains human-entered in Song Details.
7+
- PASS generated ID remains `camelCase(Name) + "-" + Classification`.
8+
- PASS generated ID is read-only/derived.
9+
- PASS classification help remains visible and useful.
10+
- PASS Intro, Verse, Chorus, Bridge, Outro, and Custom sections are supported.
11+
- PASS empty sections are not shown as populated Available Sections.
12+
- PASS populated Available Sections show metrics.
13+
- PASS Song Sequence supports Add, Duplicate, Move Up, Move Down, and Remove.
14+
- PASS Parse Guided Song Sheet updates canonical model, Octave Timeline, diagnostics, JSON Details, and status.
15+
- PASS Regenerate Arrangement warns on manual notes before overwriting and reports results.
16+
17+
Stale State:
18+
- PASS no stale Song Sheet state was observed after parse/regenerate in targeted UAT.
19+
- PASS sequence rejection of missing/unpopulated sections remains covered.
20+
21+
Ownership:
22+
- PASS Song Details owns song metadata.
23+
- PASS Song Sheet owns musical sections, sequence, generation targets, parse, and regenerate.
24+
- PASS Warnings and Diagnostics remain derived surfaces.
25+
26+
Remaining Future:
27+
- FUTURE sequence drag/drop remains red/unwired.
28+
- FUTURE history/snapshot controls remain red/unwired.
29+

‎docs/dev/reports/PR_26146_221_240_ssot_ownership_matrix.md‎

Lines changed: 28 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,28 @@
1+
# PR_26146_221_240 SSoT Ownership Matrix
2+
3+
Canonical Value | Editable Owner | Derived / Non-owning Displays
4+
--- | --- | ---
5+
`music.songs[].name` | Song Details | Song list, NAV selected song, Export readiness, Diagnostics JSON
6+
`music.songs[].classification` | Song Details | Classification guide, Export readiness, Manifest readiness
7+
`music.songs[].id` | Generated by Song Details | Read-only ID field, generated ID preview, Export readiness, JSON Details
8+
`music.songs[].studioArrangement.tempo` | Song Sheet | Sequence duration, timeline diagnostics
9+
`music.songs[].studioArrangement.key` | Song Sheet | Song summaries, JSON Details
10+
`music.songs[].studioArrangement.style` | Song Sheet | Song summaries, classification guidance, JSON Details
11+
`music.songs[].director.notes` | Song Details | Diagnostics JSON
12+
`music.songs[].director.usage` | Song Setup Game Usage | Export readiness, Manifest readiness
13+
`music.songs[].studioArrangement.songSheet.sections` | Song Sheet | Available Sections, section metrics, timeline labels
14+
`music.songs[].studioArrangement.songSheet.sequence` | Song Sequence builder | Timeline build order, Export readiness, Manifest readiness
15+
`music.songs[].studioArrangement.songSheet.applyTargets` | Song Sheet Apply Song Sheet To | Generation target summary
16+
`music.songs[].studioArrangement.lanes` | Song Sheet generation and Octave Timeline canvas editing | Diagnostics, JSON Details, note counts, Export readiness
17+
`music.songs[].studioArrangement.previewLaneSettings` | Instruments tab | Timeline quick summaries, audition range
18+
`tools.midi-studio-v2.activeSongId` | Song list and song actions | NAV selected label, Export readiness
19+
`tools.midi-studio-v2.selectedInstrumentId` | Timeline quick select and Instruments row select | Audition keyboard, selected editor display
20+
`export metadata/render targets` | Export tab | Diagnostics Export Readiness
21+
22+
Final Findings:
23+
- PASS one editable owner per canonical value.
24+
- PASS derived fields are read-only/display-only.
25+
- PASS Diagnostics is read-only except Copy JSON and Clear Status.
26+
- PASS Export JSON remains separate from rendered audio Save WAV/MP3/OGG controls.
27+
- PASS incomplete future controls are red/unwired and do not claim ownership as working controls.
28+

‎docs/dev/reports/PR_26146_221_240_timeline_report.md‎

Lines changed: 29 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,29 @@
1+
# PR_26146_221_240 Octave Timeline Report
2+
3+
Status: PASS
4+
5+
Verified:
6+
- PASS canvas editing.
7+
- PASS note toggle.
8+
- PASS drag paint.
9+
- PASS drag erase.
10+
- PASS hover and selected cell state.
11+
- PASS piano audition from the canvas keyboard.
12+
- PASS section colors.
13+
- PASS section labels.
14+
- PASS clicking a section label selects the matching sequence item.
15+
- PASS frozen Bar/Beat remains visible during scrolling.
16+
- PASS timeline scrolling preserves header visibility.
17+
- PASS playback synchronization keeps playhead and Bar/Beat moving during play and loop.
18+
19+
Stale Render Defects:
20+
- PASS no stale render defect was observed after song/sequence/regeneration/instrument changes in targeted UAT.
21+
- PASS parse/regenerate updates timeline section headers and lane data.
22+
23+
Ownership:
24+
- PASS Octave Timeline owns canvas note editing plus quick select/mute/solo/hide.
25+
- PASS it does not duplicate Instruments tab ownership for editable instrument settings.
26+
27+
Remaining Future:
28+
- No normal-user workflow blocker remains in this area.
29+

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)