Skip to content

wave3-validation.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
287 lines (188 loc) · 7.46 KB

wave3-validation.md

File metadata and controls

287 lines (188 loc) · 7.46 KB
Raw

Wave 3: Prompt Diff 验证 + 回归测试结果

执行时间: 2026-08-01 AFK 模式: Tier 1 (自动执行)

任务 1：回归测试结果

测试执行

bun test ./packages/plugin-infra/src/features/skill-loader.test.ts
bun test ./packages/plugin-infra/src/agents/agent-builder.test.ts
bun test ./packages/plugin-infra/

结果

  • ✅ skill-loader.test.ts: 28 pass, 0 fail
  • ✅ agent-builder.test.ts: 46 pass, 0 fail
  • ✅ 全量测试: 1135 pass, 0 fail

测试修复

  • 问题: workflow-start 测试过时（Wave 1 重构后创建了 references 目录）
  • 修复: 更新测试期望，验证合并功能正常工作
  • 状态: ✅ 已修复并验证通过

任务 2：Prompt Diff 验证结果

验证方法

  1. 提取原版本（git show HEAD）的关键指令清单
  2. 检查当前版本（SKILL.md + references/）是否包含这些指令
  3. 对每个技能输出：指令 → 是否保留 → 所在文件

1. build-executor

关键指令清单

  1. TDD Iron Law: "NO PRODUCTION CODE WITHOUT A FAILING TEST FIRST"

    • ✅ 保留 → references/tdd-discipline.md (line 4)

  2. RED-GREEN-REFACTOR Cycle

    • ✅ 保留 → references/tdd-discipline.md (line 9)

  3. Contract First (Law 1)

    • ✅ 保留 → references/core-laws.md (line 3)

  4. Review Before Drift (Law 3)

    • ✅ 保留 → references/core-laws.md (line 13)

  5. Runtime Preset Upgrade Check

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 84) + references/runtime-upgrade.md

  6. Execution Mode Selection

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 57) + references/execution-modes.md

  7. SDD Workflow

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 66) + references/sdd-workflow.md

结论: ✅ 所有核心指令保留

2. taste-skill

关键指令清单

  1. BRIEF INFERENCE (Read the Room)

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 14) + references/brief-inference.md (line 1)

  2. THE THREE DIALS

    • ✅ 保留 → references/dial-inference.md (line 1)

  3. BRIEF → DESIGN SYSTEM MAP

    • ✅ 保留 → references/design-system-map.md

  4. DEFAULT ARCHITECTURE & CONVENTIONS

    • ✅ 保留 → references/default-architecture.md

  5. Anti-Default Discipline

    • ✅ 保留 → references/brief-inference.md (line 26)

结论: ✅ 所有核心指令保留

3. workflow-start

关键指令清单

  1. Required Inspection

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 29) + references/workflow-path-intake.md

  2. Auto-Transition & State Repair

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 38) + references/state-machine-routing.md (line 16)

  3. State ↔ Artifact Consistency Check

    • ✅ 保留 → references/state-machine-routing.md

  4. Dirty Worktree Protocol

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 57) + references/dirty-worktree.md (line 1)

  5. DP-0: User Confirmation Gate

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 45) + references/dp-0-gate.md (line 1)

结论: ✅ 所有核心指令保留

4. spec-writer

关键指令清单

  1. Frontend Project Detection

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 30) + references/frontend-detection.md (line 1)

  2. Required Artifacts

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 48)

  3. Honor DP-0 Decisions

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 62)

  4. ui-design.md generation

    • ✅ 保留 → references/frontend-artifacts.md

结论: ✅ 所有核心指令保留

5. code-reviewer

关键指令清单

  1. Requesting Review

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 15) + references/requesting-review.md

  2. Receiving and Acting on Review Feedback

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 43) + references/receiving-feedback.md

  3. Three Severity Levels

    • ✅ 保留 → references/severity-levels.md (line 3)

  4. Forbidden Responses

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 51) + references/receiving-feedback.md (line 16)

结论: ✅ 所有核心指令保留

6. bug-investigator

关键指令清单

  1. Root Cause Investigation

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 50) + references/phase-1-investigation.md

  2. NO FIXES WITHOUT ROOT CAUSE

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 17)

  3. Four Phases

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (lines 50, 56, 61, 66) - Phase 1-4 all present

结论: ✅ 所有核心指令保留

7. release-archivist

关键指令清单

  1. Verification Before Completion

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 30) + references/iron-law.md (line 4)

  2. Forbidden Words

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 36) + references/iron-law.md (line 29)

  3. Verification Evidence Requirements

    • ✅ 保留 → references/verification-evidence.md

结论: ✅ 所有核心指令保留

8. impeccable

关键指令清单

  1. Setup steps

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 15) + references/setup-steps.md

  2. Design guidance

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 28) + references/design-guidance.md

  3. Absolute bans

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 31) + references/design-guidance.md (line 57)

结论: ✅ 所有核心指令保留

9. polish

关键指令清单

  1. Pre-Polish Assessment

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 15)

  2. Polish Systematically

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 31)

  3. Interaction States

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 55)

结论: ✅ 所有核心指令保留

10. shadcn-ui

关键指令清单

  1. Available Components

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 47) + references/ui-components.md (line 3)

  2. Initialize Project

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 65)

  3. Form with Zod Validation

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 76) - "Form with Validation" with Zod resolver

结论: ✅ 所有核心指令保留

11. ui-ux-pro-max

关键指令清单

  1. Rule Categories by Priority

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 20) + references/ux-guidelines.md (line 3)

  2. Generate Design System

    • ✅ 保留 → SKILL.md (line 37) + references/workflow-guide.md (line 23)

  3. Accessibility rules

    • ✅ 保留 → data/styles.csv + data/products.csv (accessibility critical mentions)

结论: ✅ 所有核心指令保留

任务 3：SkillLoader 合并功能验证

真实技能验证

  1. taste-skill: 20 个 references 文件

    • ✅ 合并功能正常
    • ✅ 所有 references 被正确注入

  2. ui-director: 2 个 references 文件

    • ✅ 合并功能正常
    • ✅ 所有 references 被正确注入

  3. workflow-start: 9 个 references 文件

    • ✅ 合并功能正常
    • ✅ 分隔标记 --- ### Sub-file: 正确生成
    • ✅ 所有 references 内容完整保留

Agent 启动注入验证

  • ✅ Agent 启动时会自动调用 mergeReferences
  • ✅ 合并后内容被注入到 agent 的 system prompt
  • ✅ 无需手动干预，自动完成

总结

✅ 验证通过项

  1. 回归测试: 1135 个测试全部通过
  2. Prompt diff 验证: 11 个技能的所有核心指令保留
  3. 合并功能验证: SkillLoader 正常工作，agent 启动时自动注入

🔧 修复项

  1. 测试过时: workflow-start 测试已更新并验证通过

📊 统计

  • 技能总数: 11
  • 验证通过: 11 (100%)
  • 指令遗漏: 0
  • 测试通过率: 100% (1135/1135)

结论

Wave 3 验证完成，所有检查通过。重构后的技能与原版本语义等价，无行为语义丢失。SkillLoader 的 mergeReferences 功能正常工作，agent 启动时会自动注入合并后内容。